Shutdown is over, but polarizing parties live on, KU scholar says

Fri, 10/25/2013


Megan Schmidt
KU News Service

LAWRENCE — Sixteen days probably never seemed so long to the politicians sparring and federal employees furloughed by the U.S. government shutdown this month.

The time pales in comparison, however, to the 589 days the Belgians endured without a national government from 2010-2011, a result of a cultural divide between the nation’s Dutch speakers, who live in the north, and southern French speakers. Even two years after reconciliation, questions linger as to whether Belgium will someday split into two separate countries.

The U.S. shutdown highlighted a different kind of rift: the conflict between Democrats and Republicans. But could tension between the parties ever dissolve American government for good?

“Some people wonder if we can continue to survive when we’re this polarized,” said Alan Arwine, Western democracies scholar and political science lecturer at the University of Kansas. “The partisanship gap in Congress is wider than it has been since 1879” — the year scholars began measuring party polarization in Congress.

From the U.S. to Belgium, Arwine and co-author Lawrence Mayer, with the University of Texas, examine how changes in social structures, demographics and other issues impact political parties and policy in their new book, “The Changing Basis of Political Conflict in Advanced Western Democracies.”

It’s not really geographically feasible to split the U.S. into two new homelands — one for conservatives, one for liberals — but the fact remains that the parties have changed over the past several decades, Arwine said.

Fifty years ago, social class was the most reliable factor for determining whether Americans considered themselves liberals or conservatives. The traditional left-to-right spectrum is based on “politics of interest” in which, broadly speaking, workers support political parties that protect their rights (fair wages and working conditions). Business owners, on the other hand, support the party that rallies for lower taxes and fewer business regulations. 

Arwine and Mayer’s book describes how this view of the parties is losing influence. Filling its vacuum are the “politics of identity,” in which groups define themselves by a shared set of values. Now, instead of picketing for higher wages, voters focus on social issues such as abortion, same-sex marriage and immigration.

“The concept of identity is about the answer to the questions ‘who am I?’ and ‘what is the purpose and meaning of my life?’” Arwine said. “Identity is about feeling.”

Although Belgium’s conflict stems more from cultural differences than social issues, it’s politics of identity that led to that government’s shutdown.

Politics of identity are shaping other European nations, too. In an act widely viewed as an attempt to preserve its own culture, France banned face-covering veils. Throughout Europe, anti-immigrant platforms are central to a number of emerging and growing political parties.

For Americans, it seems the further removed the U.S. becomes from its post-World War II outlook, the more entrenched the parties become in politics of identity.

“During the war, everyone felt they had to contribute in some way, and after the war, people maintained that attitude that they were all in this together,” Arwine said. “A lot of wealthy people felt it was simply their duty to pay their taxes and give back to the government that educated their workers and provided the infrastructure that allowed their businesses to operate.”

Today, that mentality has changed, Arwine said.

“You hear people say, ‘I built it myself, and if the government takes taxes, they’re stealing from me,’” he said.

Recently, movements such as the Tea Party and Occupy Wall Street have considerably heightened ideological resistance between the two parties, even though they’re not endorsed by either party, Arwine and Mayer wrote.

During Barack Obama’s first term, there was an unprecedented degree of party line voting in Congress. The president’s health care bill passed without a single Republican vote in the House of Representatives. In 2009, his $787 billion stimulus package was opposed by every House Republican.

By welcoming the influence of an interest group like the Tea Party, even without endorsing them, Republicans alienated more centrist politicians from the party. On the other hand, Democrats appeared to have take on the pursuit of an egalitarian distribution of material well-being and social justice by opening up to the Occupy movement.

As for whether these shifts will permanently alter the political landscape — turning American politics either more elite or more populist — it’s too early to say, Arwine and Mayer wrote.

Can a new species of frog have a doppelgänger? KU researchers say yes. Learn more about the discovery here: Tags: #KUdiscoveries #KUresearch #KUstudents #Frog #LookAlike

Poet offers insights to Jayhawk experience through wordplay "Welcome to KU. Where questions rest, in stacks of answers from the past. …" Listen to Topher Enneking, a spoken word poet and former KU football player, as he weaves the experience of KU and its traditions through this storytelling and wordplay performance. Learn more about KU traditions at Welcome to KU. Where questions rest in stacks of answers from the past. Where dreams crawl out of bed And learn to walk Uphill both ways. Where freshmen stand on stilts And hang from the rafters, While the wheat waves In a fieldhouse Where the Phog rolls in Helping us to see Through the past into the future. Haunting hosts giving handouts in a heritage Too heavy to grasp til you add to it. So it may be born anew, Allowing our boots to stand in the ash of oppression’s hate But shine bright as the sun While war cries of warriors past Ring in our ears long after their battles are won. Memorials telling time, “you don’t have to stand still.” Because the top of the world Is just up that Hill. Where our natural history is an awe-struck echo Of world’s fair and equal Past, present and future, prelude and sequel. Where our flags fly above planes. Where we build in chalks that can’t be erased. Stone edifices made to last So you would walk Past their doors, down their halls And let your voice fill their room. Because only in empty silence can destruction loom. So stand tall. Wrap your arms around this crowd Sing our alma mater and sing it out loud. Let your voice sing in chorus and reach other nations Beckoning new Jayhawks to spark new collaborations Because you are the mortar that will hold these walls upright. Your future Your dreams are why Jayhawks did fight For the tradition before you Was merely prelude For what will come next now that you’re at KU.

One of 34 U.S. public institutions in the prestigious Association of American Universities
26 prestigious Rhodes Scholars — more than all other Kansas colleges combined
Nearly $290 million in financial aid annually
1 of 9 public universities with outstanding study abroad programs.
—U.S. News & World Report
46 nationally ranked graduate programs.
—U.S. News & World Report
Top 50 nationwide for size of library collection.
$260.5 million in externally funded research expenditures
23rd nationwide for service to veterans —"Best for Vets," Military Times