Study reveals troubling disparities in prescribing opioids for patients with nonmalignant chronic pain

LAWRENCE — According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, more than 90 Americans die every day by overdosing on opioids. While heroin and synthetic opioids such as fentanyl account for part of the crisis, in 2015 about 2 million people in the U.S. suffered from substance use disorders related to prescription opioid pain relievers.

Now, a recent study from the University of Kansas School of Pharmacy has uncovered disturbing trends in prescribing opioids for nonmalignant chronic pain (defined as pain lasting for more than three months not associated with cancer). Published in the journal Pain Medicine, the analysis of 690 million outpatient visits related to nonmalignant chronic pain between 2000 and 2007 suggests prescriptions of opioids are influenced by non-medical factors such as a patient’s form of insurance, geographic region and patient’s relationship to the provider. These differences are difficult to interpret based on the complexity of treatment and the challenges of determining appropriate opioid prescribing.

Among the key findings:

• Patients age 35-49 were 1.47 times more likely to receive opioids compared with other age groups
• Patient visits with primary care physicians were 1.83 times more likely to result in opioid prescriptions than specialty physicians
• Patients with publicly funded insurance were more likely to receive opioids compared with patients with private insurance
• Patients in the U.S. South were more likely to be prescribed opioids
• Patients of Hispanic ethnicity were less likely to receive opioids

“More patients are dying from opioid overdoes than car accidents, based on 2015 CDC data,” said Rafia Rasu, lead author of the study and associate professor of pharmacy practice at KU. “We take so many precautions about car seats and seat belts, but this is obviously a serious public health problem right now that needs immediate attention as more people are dying now from drug overdose.”

Rasu and co-author Maureen Knell of the University of Missouri Kansas City School of Pharmacy performed statistical-software analysis on data from the National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey to determine predictors of opioid use based on patient-specific factors.

The researchers found social and cultural factors seem to play too large a factor in determining which patients receive opioid prescriptions.

“Prescribers aren’t always following guidelines,” Rasu said. “The prescription has to be appropriately written, need to verify if a patient already has tried something else as a first-line therapy or not. From a snapshot, this is what we see and this needs to be looked at more carefully and longitudinally. Prescribers could more closely follow guidelines like those from the American Academy of Pain Medicine and CDC.”

Rasu recommended more use of “prior authorization” when prescribing opioids — a constraint requiring physicians and others to get approval from an insurance provider to prescribe a medication.

“It’s a technique that requires prior authorization so they need to take an extra step to get opioids,” she said. “Effective pain coping strategies and standardized protocol and education curriculum may help to change the culture. Opioids help to relieve pain, but much more caution should be taken as they can be dangerous to some patients as opioids possess addictive properties. Recent national priority to promote prescription drug monitoring program showed promising results with patient safety and health.”

Hispanic patients were 30 percent less likely to receive opioid prescriptions than non-Hispanic patients.

“This could be due to a lack of insurance coverage or ability to pay,” the authors wrote. “It could also be due to possible language and/or cultural barriers, resulting in underreporting of pain and instilling more physician fear concerning their patients’ ability to safely take opioids.”

The study showed cultural factors could play a role in prescribing opioids as well. The research revealed patient visits in the Southern region of the United States were 1.36 times more likely than those in the Northeast region to list treatment with opioid pain relievers, which correlates with a higher rate in the number of opioid-related deaths in the Southern region.

“It could be due to attitudes towards pain management and norms of practice we possess in different clinical settings. We have differing expectations,” Rasu said. “This needs to be looked at — why is there geographical variation? What needs to be done?”

Rasu hopes her research results will influence stakeholders up and down the decision-making process.

“Especially policymakers,” she said. “They need to look at it carefully as well as public health officials and health care providers. They need to understand these things are happening around the nation. Also pharmacists, nurses, physicians — everyone involved in taking care of these patients — should take a look at this.”