New ethical approach to environmental issues would avoid 'problem shifting,' law scholar says


LAWRENCE — When governments have attempted to address environmental problems in recent decades, they have often simply shifted the problem elsewhere or created a new problem for others. A University of Kansas law professor is among a group of scholars who published a study pointing out such environmental problem shifting and proposing “strange loop ethics” as a method to rethink critical legal issues.

Robin Kundis Craig, Robert A. Schroeder Distinguished Professor of Law at KU, an expert in water and environmental law, said it has been known for years that new solutions are necessary for environmental problems in the Anthropocene, the geological epoch in which humans are the driving force behind the planet’s environment and ecosystems. Yet governance bodies around the world often lack the flexibility or imagination to consider new approaches.

“For at least a couple of decades, scholars have recognized that the Anthropocene and climate change require being a little more flexible in how we approach problems,” Craig said. “New circumstances require increased flexibility as well as cycles of learning. Having the ability to come back and adjust is necessary. What strange loop ethics and our proposal says is we’ve too long assumed the same ethical operating systems across scenarios.”

For the new article in the journal Ecology & Society, Craig and co-authors present case studies in fisheries management and carbon governance as situations in which problems have been shifted rather than solved. In the case of the former, governments around the world have taken the approach that fisheries should take the maximum number of fish possible without harming the long-term sustainability of species. That approach, generally referred to as “maximum sustainable yield,” has never worked well to keep fish stocks from being depleted. 

More importantly for strange loop ethics, the authors wrote, it has often worked to shift limitations on fishing to small nations, indigenous fisheries, certain species and waterways while allowing large commercial fleets and richer fishing nations to decimate fish stocks globally.

According to the authors, the attempts to solve the problem have resulted in a loop in which new problems are created while the initial issue remains unsolved. And while government, economic or other forms of inertia have kept governing bodies making the same decisions, recognizing that the higher-level ethics and philosophies that drove such failing approaches in the past may no longer be workable is necessary to make progress, they wrote.

“Maybe we need to go back and revisit the premise that we should take the maximum number of fish that we think we can,” Craig said. “Maybe we end up hurting small-scale or subsistence fishing and end up prioritizing the large-scale, economic powers that can afford to operate under that system like China and the U.S.”

The authors propose that governing bodies can take an approach in which they recognize a problem and ask if the approaches that have been taken thus far have worked — or if they are, in fact, even addressing the problem. 

Craig shared the example of dams in the western United States or attempts to save endangered species around the world. In the former, policy in the early 20th century was essentially there was no such thing as a bad dam, in that they provided power, flood control, recreation and other benefits. However, time has proven that dams cause other problems, such as threats to certain fish species. In the latter case, attempts to save species have often overlooked that a species’ traditional habitat is no longer capable of supporting traditional populations of the animal.

While recognizing there are challenges to implementing new approaches, namely those of inertia, governance structure and legal barriers, governance bodies can change, and the most likely way to effect such change is through small-scale experimentation rather than top-down mandates, the authors wrote. Examples of new approaches include addressing fishery problems through measures like quota-based fishing or closing off certain areas of oceans to fishing or dam removal.

The study was co-written with David Angeler and Salvador Sanchez-Carrillo of the National Museum of Natural Sciences in Madrid; Carolina Cuadrado Bastos of the Complutense University of Madrid; Julie Maybee of City University of New York; Rakhyun Kim of Utrecht University; Niko Soininen of the University of Eastern Finland; and Daniel DeCaro of the University of Louisville.

A new ethical consideration in which governance bodies tasked with environmental oversight do not simply keep attempting to paper over problems and instead ask new questions about what can and should be done and the ramifications has come due, according to the researchers.

“Let’s start having the discussion,” Craig said. “What values do we base our decisions on? Who inherits the problem when we think we have solved it? How do we get justice and equality through resource management?”

Mon, 11/16/2026

author

Mike Krings

Media Contacts